All comments of User Silky
In response to Fried Chikan's comment
Top 10 Asses in JAV 2023I don't disagree with anything you said. If all asses were the same then there would be no point watching porn because nobody wants to see the same thing all the time. Plus like you said, there are certain qualities that are iconic and/or exclusive to a specific ass which all ties back to bone structure, bone thickness, height, hip width, fat to muscle ratio, and even the way their bodies store fat or grow muscle (fat and muscle composition). One thing I will say though is that there are asses that are definitely not as appealing or exquisite as some people hype them up to be. I'll use Alice Otsu as an example. It looks round and at least partially toned in covers as opposed to just having a lot of protrusion and overall size. But when you see it in videos, it actually has a square shape and zero muscle. In other words, it has no presence of any objective qualities that makes an ass a truly jaw-dropping and timeless ass. I'm not trying to say Alice Otsu is an acquired taste or an ass that only big booty admirers would truly understand. I guess what I'm saying is that it does have that eye candy some people would want. Yeah, it's big and it jiggles a lot because it's pure fat. It just doesn't explore the other 10 booty qualities (or however many there are). That's why I was confused when I was going through this list because the list has no consistency. It makes more sense to title the list "My Personal Top 10 Favorite Asses to Watch in JAV" because a "Top 10 Asses in JAV" list would be consistent and align with all the traits that truly make an ass connect with the most amount of people. It would be like me making a list titled "Top 10 Anal Performers" and then having like half the list with actresses that aren't actually enthusiastic but are there just because I personally like watching them get ass fucked when in reality it should be titled "My Personal Top 10 Anal Performers." I know everyone has different preferences when it comes to ass. But you have to keep in mind that there are asses which are objectively better than others. I could sit here and claim Maria Nagai has the best ass in JAV history. She is popular, she is fuckable, but her ass strays so far from ass territory that it's basically just an over inflated hump of cellulite with the most awkward protrusion. Not to mention the fact that it's totally disproportionate to her actual body which is of course something that typically comes with fake asses. If people are into her ass then to each their own. I'm just saying that if someone finds a certain ass appealing, it doesn't mean that person can almost ignorantly and selfishly (for lack of a better phrase) claim it as one of the top asses in the industry. It all goes back to the word "objective." Not everyone will look at an objective list and agree with all the actresses or even any of them because it is impossible to please everyone. The list I'm looking at here is inherently a personal favorites list as opposed to a list that people could look at and at least see something that is congruent and gets as close as possible when it comes to keeping it in tune with all the qualities that come with an ass that has a perfect / commonly acknowledged (ideal) fat to muscle ratio. One thing to note is that if I was to make an objective list, I would've included Yayoi Mizuki, but since she gained weight her ass has lost some of the shape that it. Before the weight gain she probably had the most flawless bubble shape in all of JAV. Also, having Aoi Tsukasa and Shiori Tsukada in the same list is a perfect example of what I meant by this list lacking consistency. Aoi Tsukasa's ass is definitely heaven sent. It has the kind of shape and conformity that no chick would be able to duplicate in the gym. It's an absolute genetic miracle that nobody should overlook. It's undoubtedly a top tier ass. If I was to make an objective list, I wouldn't put her in there just because it's a bit too muscular (tight). It's lacking that jiggle and bubble that comes with having the perfect mix of muscle and fat. But otherwise, she has an ass that I'm sure a lot of actresses are jealous of and would easily rival some of the other names in Panking's list if it had a bit more juice to it. Besides her not really fitting into an objective list as peachy, juicy, jiggleness are traits everyone wants to see in an ass (not that it's always required, but in this context it would be), her ass is fine the way it is. It's almost surreal to look at and worth all the praise it gets. Shiori Tsukada's ass has a surprisingly nice shape for an ass that ridiculously massive so I can see the appeal. It doesn't just look like a whole bunch of fat dangling and flailing around like whale blubber. It's probably the nicest an ass that massive can look before it's quite literally just a big heap of fat. It's definitely big enough to where she gets diminishing returns due to the fact that an ass with that much volume means it's practically unrealistic for it to attain presence from the qualities that would come with an ass like Kurea Hasumi's. I'm not opposed to big asses, but it does get to the point where an ass is just too big because it ends up just being big for the sake of having a lot of ass taking up the screen. If Shiori's was any bigger, I wouldn't even be able to see why people like it. I'm not a hater by any means. I can acknowledge what she brings to the industry as there's obviously a reason such a massive ass has become a household name in the industry. Though to be fair, Shiori's ass is that massive because of her big bone structure and wide hips so her ass will never live up to certain standards, but as I said, it still delivers in other ways. You mentioned how we should take thighs into consideration when analyzing asses. I'd say we shouldn't pay attention to thighs when making an objective list based on asses because when an actress loses weight, she's not just going to lose weight in her ass, she will lose weight throughout her whole body including her thighs. Thigh thickness along with the actual muscularity of thighs has a lot to do with bone size and genetics. If an actress has a top tier bubble butt, but she feels her thighs are too thick, she can't slim down her thighs without also slimming down her ass. Of course if she does that anyway, she could train her ass to regain the size, but it would end up becoming too muscular in the process. Certain body types and bone thickness can't support specific types of thighs as well so when you're making an objective ass list, you need to solely focus on the ass itself. I see what you're saying though. The slimmer or thicker thighs are, the more or less of a foundation there is for the ass to sit on. Thighs act as like a parking spot for ass. Depending on the thickness and shape of the thighs, it will contribute to the ass. Though it's not like the list would be wrong if we solely honed in on their asses because we'll subconsciously know their thighs are just as mesmerizing as their ass since the ass in question can't have the appearance it has without having the thighs to give her ass that appearance. I get what you're saying though. There are some actresses with next level thighs that are lacking in the ass department. Or they have an impeccable booty, but their thighs lack the shape and size to really give their ass that extra "oomph." But I think you would have to be rushing to finish the list in a short time if you were to end up picking actresses with an objectively flawless ass that don't have the proper legs (foundation) to make their asses actually sit well on their frames. Some actresses also have thick thighs and really wide hips which gives the illusion that they have a big ass especially from certain angles when in reality their ass is either non existent or it's just too small for such a huge foundation. Everything considered, all asses have their place and fill a different need while excelling in and/or accentuating specific booty traits people are looking for when it comes to ass appreciation. But I do stand firm on the belief that asses with the perfect fat to muscle ratio gives access to the dozen different qualities that ass appreciators love to indulge in. Most people would probably really appreciate a list like that and for the few who wouldn't agree with it, they wouldn't be able to contest it because you can't contest an objective list. Their argument would be that some massive booty or really tight booty they like isn't in the list. Essentially, the goal is just to encompass the full spectrum of ass qualities to showcase 10 actresses that have a complete ass in the sense that a person could get a view, taste, and feel of every aspect a man could want all from a single ass. For all the people who have a specific preference of ass, you could make an objective list for those too like "Top 10 Biggest Asses with Perfect Shape in JAV." Or if people purely want size title it "Top 10 Biggest Asses in JAV (from non-chubby actresses)."
The title of the list is misleading. It's not true to the meaning. You took your favorites and just claim them as the top 10. I'd like to see you make a list titled "Top 10 Objectively Best Asses in JAV." That means a list that doesn't involve any kind of biases that are based on performance, the amount of jiggle, etc. Once the biases are out of the way, you need to build a list of names that have asses that have the perfect fat to muscle ratio. An ass that is too muscular doesn't fully cover the spectrum of what an ass should entail because an ass with next to zero fat won't really resonate with most people and will have zero jiggle. An ass that that is too fat gives that atmosphere of laziness and it also removes most (if not all) the shape which pretty much just ends up being a whole bunch of blubber just for the sake of size. Now when an ass has the perfect mix of both fat and muscle, there will be a more or less flawlessly round shape. To put this in perspective, there are some asses in JAV that are iconic for many reasons and even look really round when bent over and what not, but if you see them standing, it will either be full of cellulite, be flat, or even have a square shape. For example, Alice Otsu's ass is actually a square shape when you see her standing. Secondly, there will be a calm and fluid jiggle to add the perfect mix of elegance and sexiness as opposed to an ass with pure size where the jiggling is so intense that it's sole purpose is just to signify her ass is almost purely fat. An ass with a calm and fluid jiggle thanks to the perfect fat and muscle ratio will give it that plushy pillow effect as well to add that mix of tenderness and softness. Thirdly, the ass needs to have a fair presence of meat. Not so much that it protrudes to the point where it overpowers the other qualities, but just enough to where it will add to the shock factor of an ass that is not only tight and round, but also has the perfect amount of presence (meat) to harmonize with all the qualities that come with the perfect fat to muscle ratio. Sora Amakawa is a perfect example of an ass with the perfect fat to muscle ratio which is what gives a woman an objectively top tier ass. I would use her as a reference to make the objectively best asses list.