2024 Debut Review - Ayu Anzai

Ayu is an actress that is actually a redebut. She debuted the first time over a decade ago and has been retired over 7 years by my count. I never watched her back then, especially with her not working with big studios. I spent a while deciding if I wanted to watch Ayu or not given she's not technically a debut even if they're classifying her as such. The way I see it, this whole series is designed on me finding new actresses to watch (and then share with everyone). It's more a spirit vs letter of the law thing and I'm more inclined to pick on the spirit side. There have already been cases where I've found out they weren't a debut after I watched them, like the case with Rei Kimura and Mei Itsukaichi. More than anything though I just want to watch actresses I will like and if you show me a big titty milf like this how am I supposed to say no?

Facially I was a bit lukewarm on her. Her age is clearly showing at this point and she had a lot of makeup on to compensate. She reminded me a lot of Tsubasa Amami in that regard with excessive eye shadow and the long eyelashes. I don't think that is necessarily off-putting but I tend to prefer actresses who are a little more natural looking. I think she honestly might look better more natural, especially without the lighter contact lenses she seemed to be wearing.

Her tits were obviously fantastic, big and juicy as hell. She's listed at a whopping 101J and they were every bit as good as they were big. There were a lot of different camera angles to help capture them, especially from underneath that gave you an excellent underboob perspective. They had surprisingly good elasticity considering what her age likely is, and I expected them to be quite a bit saggier. I also honestly wouldn't mind them being a bit saggier either which means if she sticks around long enough I won't be complaining.

Her ass was also quite nice, surprisingly so. When I saw it in doggy the first time I was like, oh okay that's not bad. When I saw her standing in the shower I changed my tune immediately as I realized it was actually quite something. Then when I saw her in reverse cowgirl it all came together. She definitely is someone that needs the right angle / arch to make it stand out but when it does it's very nice. It's just naturally quite juicy.

Ayu's body was good but not great. I found her to be the definition of thicc, just generally juicy. She struck me as being just a bit too juicy in some parts, especially her midsection, so she wasn't quite as ideally proportioned. If you've been watching JAV for a few years and remember Kaori you'll know exactly what I'm talking about. If you like 'em thicc then by all means, Ayu is your gal, but for me I do like them just a little bit slimmer these days.

Ayu as a performer was pretty forgettable. She had a lot of your typical big titty milf issues where she would look away or moan without rhyme or reason.

Ayu's kissing was quite unremarkable as well. She didn't really know how to French the guy, though perhaps the plot brought that out a little bit. It seemed clumsy and awkward, unfortunately.

Ayu's paizuri was pretty solid. Some blowzuri in the mix along with what generally seemed pretty respectable. Yeah, maybe she didn't maintain the level of enthusiasm some others can but she's also a milf that generally exude a lot less vibrancy in their performances. I'm honestly happy enough she could just keep it properly between her tits and not make it look terrible.

A guy goes and visits his girlfriend and while there meets her hot stepmom. When his girlfriend goes out of town and he's home alone with her, well, one thing leads to another. She's hotter than his girlfriend, he's horny, she's single and not getting action - the perfect storm.

The film came off as rather basic to me but not necessarily in a bad way. The film was just all about him and his girlfriend's stepmom embracing each other. Slowly as they both realized this is what they needed and then as they explored it further. Breakfast barely clothed or barely being able to contain their lust after coming back from a konbini run. I also just generally liked the idea of her being a single stepmom and what that meant for a plot when it's so often not that. Sure, he was still cheating, but she wasn't and it felt a lot more fitting. Oh right, she actually wants it because she hasn't had sex in years. There were certainly ways to improve it but for what it w as I didn't really hate it on the surface level. Her as a performer was a different story and I do wish she got a bit more into it but I think knowing she was likely not really being that loving for a while gave her a slight pass.

Ayu's career is looking pretty solid so far if you look just at her redebut. A milf like her starting off at Fitch is honestly a really strong positive for her. I typically expect her caliber of milf to just start off at Madonna so anything not Madonna on the right side of the fence is good. I would expect her career (if she sticks around long enough) to have her go to Madonna in the middle and to low-tier milf studios like Aleddin or Ruby at some point down the road. She could just as easily have started off at a much worse place, especially as a redebut who had a less than stellar career before. After her initial Fitch contract she's moved to freelancing, and while M's isn't that great, Moodyz is, and I'm just happy to see she isn't relegated to those low tier studios quite yet.

When I look at Ayu I see both the best and worst of the busty milf aesthetic. On the bad side she's a pretty poor performer, she strikes me as Mako Oda levels of bad (and Mako is quite bad, trust me). That's where a lot of JAV gets the bad reputation from and I am a man of very little faith with Ayu. I don't really see any shining points from her that make me think she will improve, especially knowing it's her second stint in the industry. I'd certainly love to be proven wrong but I just don't see it happening. On the good side she is pretty textbook definition of busty milf. Like Mako Oda she's also physically very nice. I definitely don't think she's as nice as Mako (though I am very big on Mako) which means I'm not exactly sure where she will end up. Mako is a really good actress to compare to because despite how awful she is as a performer I look past it and watch her for how physically attractive she is. Maybe she might compare better to someone like Reika Takeda from last year, where I want to hope she can be good and will watch a couple more videos. I certainly do want to watch Ayu again and I certainly do expect to watch her again next year. Exactly when or how much depends on how much she films and the quality of her releases. I think knowing she is on her second stint does give me a bit of pause because she might be willing to dip easier than others. That being said, freelancing gives a lot of hope for something interesting.

This year I am doing 31 debut reviews, one each day in December. Make sure to come back tomorrow to see the next one! If you want to see which actresses I've reviewed so far, check out my advent calendar post.